Church Of Om: Has Yoga Outpaced Organized Religion?

05/21/09  Print This Post Print This Post    4 Comments   Popular   Written by Christine Garvin
  • Stumble It
With church attendance down and yoga classes up, the ancient practice may just become religion’s public enemy No. 1.

Seems as if I can’t walk out the front door without hearing about yoga these days (literally…there’s a yoga study right across the street from my apartment).

In my neck of the woods, more people seem to be coming out of yoga classes on a Sunday morning rather than church.

And it’s not just in new-age central, California, either. Retreats are abounding: everywhere from Massachusetts to Thailand, the best yoga destinations are now hotly debated around the web.

Are traditional church leaders scared? Christian televangelist Pat Robertson called yoga “spooky” a few years back:

Yet it appears that his view on yoga is rooted in misunderstanding. As one blogger put it, “Asking Robertson about yoga is about as futile as asking Paris Hilton for her insights on the theory of existentialism.”

Spiritual Or Religious?

So traditional church attendance appears to be waning. Does that mean Americans are less spiritual?

What might be considered damning to the very fabric of organized religion, a recent Huffington Post article posed an interesting theory: Americans, at least, are searching for spiritual experience over simple spiritual belief.

The author and Spiritual Program Director for Canyon Ranch Health Resorts, Jonathan Ellerby, states that:

Church attendance is down more than 10% from recent years and fewer people self-identify as Christian or religious…more and more people are connecting with regular and diverse spiritual practices such as meditation, yoga, mindfulness, expressive arts (such as dance, group singing/chanting), self-help studies, and spiritual travel.

He goes on to explain that anything in life where there is a felt-sense, like watching a sunset, connecting with a lover or pet, or even playing sports, has more impact than simply reading about it.

Even more importantly, he says: “The tolerance for guilt and passing one’s own ethics and judgment to an authority who is questionable and too human is less and less appealing.”

Yoga As Religion

Then there’s the question of whether or not yoga is a religion, or is at least rooted in one. Over the past six months, yoga has been banned by Islamic leaders in Malaysia and Indonesia due to its Hindu roots.

Food and Yoga blogger Karen Mackenzie questioned whether it’s possible for yoga and religion to work together. And Yoga Journal ran an article entitled, Is Yoga a Religion?, which noted:

There are ancient yogic texts (most notably, Patanjali’s Yoga Sutra) that many regard as scriptures, revelations of truth and wisdom meant to guide the lives of yogis down through the ages.

I can see how this might scare some leaders of organized religions, since it is giving people the ability to make choices and come to their own conclusions. Whether we explore externally via globe trotting, or internally via contemplation, breathwork, and movement, we give rise to our own truths.

And those truths may or may not look a whole lot different than what the church is telling you to believe.

For some good fun with a Christian twist, check out the farcical Yoga: A Religion for Sex Addicts.

Feature photo: adhiwus

Community Connection

Find out how some groups are doing to trademark this ancient practice in Asanas For Sale: The Privatization Of Yoga, and how to fit in yoga anytime with 7 Ancient Exercises You Can Do Anywhere.

Do you think yoga is becoming more popular than organized religion? Share your thoughts below.


  • Stumble It

About the Author

Christine Garvin

Christine Garvin is a certified Nutrition Educator and holds a MA in Holistic Health Education. She is co-editor of Brave New Traveler and founder/editor of Living Holistically...with a sense of humor. When she is not out traveling the world, she is busy writing, doing yoga, and performing hip-hop and bhangra. She also likes to pretend living in her hippie town of Fairfax, CA is like being on vacation.

4 Comments... join the discussion!

  • Ian MacKenzie replied on May 21, 2009

    I think the important message is not so much that yoga is competing with these religions, but that organized religion needs to adapt and evolve along with the times. Half the stuff in the bible was specific to the time it was written. I see nothing wrong in adopting beneficial techniques like yoga to deepen awareness, whatever your religion.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • joshywashington replied on May 22, 2009

    RANDOM BIT OF CRAZINESS FROM LANDOVERBAPTISTS.ORG
    ~ Secular scholars argue that the practice of “Yoga” is nearly 3,000 years old. We know this to be a lie because the Bible never mentions anything about it, and the Bible is the most accurate historical book ever written.~

    People who are threatened by yoga are proving what a thin candy coated shell their religious perspective is, it could melt away into depravity in one proud warrior!

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • El malo replied on May 24, 2009

    First of all, I think it is important to understand the meaning of Yoga… and of course its roots. Yoga is rooted in Hinduism and it is a method to achieve integration with ________ (god, your body, yourself, your mind….). Hatha yoga, or any physical yoga, is only the first step towards a spiritual yoga.

    Anyway, great article… Last week a friend of mine told me about a Kabalah course that was going on at the same time of my Yoga class… I went to the introductory class (which to me was very much like hearing a Brazilian evangelist) and decided to stay with my Yoga….

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • milla replied on June 8, 2009

    I think that it is a big shame for christian believers to look for something like yoga to fill there inner self! As we all know that only GOD has the power to fill a person and it’s needs that would last. Yoga has a spirit behind everything that they do. And that spirit only leads to self destruct and death eternal damnation. The people that say thy are believers are infact far from that real truth. if they seek fulfilment and spirituality with yoga. GOD is and all ways will be the only one to help and heal there mind and soul. Yoga is a cover up off satins plain to destroy GOD’s people! But you know what? The devil will never win!

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply

Leave a Comment

Get Matador in your inbox and around the web.

Sign up for our FREE weekly newsletter.


View full list of RSS feeds

Jump To Category:





Popular Stories on Matador

Review Series: Rosetta Stone TOTALe – Part 1

I must confess. My previous relationship with Rosetta S... 

How to Discern Fallacious Arguments

Writers working in nonfiction, including travel

Greenhouse Gas Clock Measures Emissions Second by Second

The debt clock? That's so passe. Manhattan now has a gr... 

A Quick and Dirty Phrasebook of Mexican Slang

You can’t come to Mexico without a bare bones underst... 

A Traveler's Secret Way To Save Gas Money

You rely on public transport while traveling. Free your... 

5 Travel Memoirs by Women

The air is getting chilly and the rainy season has begu... 

Bikes + Wine in Mendoza, Argentina

Here's what you need to know about the most popular tou... 

11 Things You Didn't Know About Che Guevara

... 

Gracefully Becoming A Golden Oldie

The advantage of youth is obvious. Rosie Horne shows us... 

6 Inspiring TED Talks About Happiness and Belief

We've collected some of the most inspirational TED talk... 




Focus



Editor Blogs

Friends