Wisdom from experience / Photo: tiago.ribeiro
“Up top,” the old man said. He demonstrated, opening wide to reveal his tongue touching the roof of his mouth. “Easy, see?”
Sure. Already the tiny hut was hot. We sat in a half circle around the rusted oil drum, five Americans and the old Aleutian. Inside the drum a fire torched, causing sweat to run down our naked torsos. A rough ceiling hung inches overhead. Heat and sweat.
A small room. The old man wanted to know if we were ready. Sure.
Gently he dipped the aged soup can into the bin of boiling water. We watched him stretch the crudely fashioned dipper over the heat. He smiled, then began to methodically pour the water onto the small rocks covering the drum. The rocks hissed and belched narrow towers of steam.
For three seconds nothing more happened. Then a blanket of heat struck, reflecting from the outer walls. The painful burn flayed my back and I felt real fear. A blur of human flesh bowled through the tiny door before me, pursued by Hell’s climate.
Then a layer of steam clouded the tiny room, diminishing visibility. Remembering the old man’s words I pressed my tongue upward.
A Traveler’s Tale
When I think on travel it’s the truest moment that comes to mind, like the old man sharing his life in the midst of Alaska.
The river wild / Photo: code poet
That my own story should strike me as a traveler’s tale seems odd. For so long I’ve idealized the true traveler. He’s always shown superior understanding, enlightenment, and fulfillment. A man of the road, heightened by awareness.
I am not that man. Yet, I’ve traveled and seen places, acted occasionally as a tourist, but attempted to learn. Did I somewhere unknowingly become the true traveler? Or am I a tourist fascinated by travel? I can only answer by returning to the beginning.
First, there was the desire to travel. Then there was the plan. We’d carry backpacks, stay in hostels and explore without a plan, all in an effort to capture the spirit of travel.
But even as we moved I felt us failing my romanticized notions. Yes, Christina and I ran to trains lugging our packs and lost our way in the streets of Venice.
We thwarted the Lonely Planet recommendations in order to find the world’s best kept dining secrets. In Rome we crossed verbal swords with an unscrupulous guide and took victory. We overcame logistical obstacles and breathed the experiences, history, and culture home couldn’t offer.
We were, in short, on vacation. And isn’t vacation the enemy of travel?
A Wealthy Warlord
That realization introduced guilt to an otherwise rewarding experience. By scanning online posts, watching documentaries, and reading insightful articles I began to educate myself on the parasitic tourist.
Words and pages filed by the Zen nomads reprimanded me for my apparent disregard for human suffering. I became, through their words, a “wealthy warlord lobbing missiles into the hearts of the environment and foreign cultures.” I was entirely disconnected from the art of travel.
So I decided to change. I couldn’t—or wouldn’t—eliminate travel. But I could determine to travel responsibly, with an eye for local immersion. Travel and understanding, I reasoned, could coexist.
Feeling my “rich, white man’s burden” lightening, I chose Alaska as a destination. Not Anchorage, Denali, or cruise ship Alaska, but working Alaska. Westbound for a job in a salmon cannery.
Go North
In western Alaska I spent a month mucking about with dead fish. I lived in housing constructed of plywood and corrugated siding, beside the gray Naknek River. Bald eagles flew over daily. A grizzly heaved himself into the mess hall dumpster occasionally.
Alaskan ship awaits cargo / Photo: author
I toiled through long hours and lost too much sleep. My coworkers were Ukrainians, Dominicans, Mexicans, Japanese and Turks. Many were Aleutian natives who annually hopped from cannery to cannery, following the fish. Together we worked and ate and walked into town.
The old man taught us about the native sweat hut. His tongue trick allowed us to grit through the inferno until we began to sweat like Aleutian men.
In the heat the old man shared a sliver of culture, a moment of camaraderie, a touch of humanity in a wild land. Something museums and tours couldn’t offer.
Since Europe and Alaska I’ve struggled with the traveler versus tourist debate. The words from both parties are too irate for sensible, worldly citizens who claim awareness. Neither group, it seems, can accept that I view my experiences as equally rewarding. So I’ve been forced to manufacture my own ideas.
To Plunge Right In
The difference between a tourist and a “true” traveler is not that their directions are so misaligned. It’s that their stopping off points differ.
Where a vacationer goes to view another place and culture a traveler goes to plunge right in. Europe for me was informative, pleasurable, and wildly exciting. It was a world where each day was a joy. Do I now know how the Italians, Swiss or English live? Not really, I tell the pundits, but I know how they welcome foreigners.
The salmon cannery showed me a side of Alaska beyond the glaciers and grizzlies. I learned what life is like for thousands of natives, but never did I misinterpret that knowledge as total understanding.
At times it was fun, mostly it was work and waiting. I wasn’t on vacation. Instead I was living ordinary life in an extraordinary place. The good was tempered by the bad.
Now when I travel I prefer to journey on a budget. Often I sleep in tents, cook meals on a camp stove, and take strangers up on offers of dinner, a backyard, or coffee.I ride a bike because it’s cheaper and more enjoyable than a car. I do these things because it’s the only way I can afford to travel.
If I won the lottery tomorrow, would I give it up for first class and fancy restaurants? Never, but I’d probably spring for a vacation once a year. I now have a tough time believing that my enjoyable week harms underdeveloped nations.
Miserable people don’t change the world.
What are your thougths on the myth of the true traveler? Share your thoughts in the comments!
About the Author
Related Posts
7 Comments... join the discussion!
-
-
I’ve gotta disagree on this one, Turner, I think it’s great to keep talking about it, especially at a place like Matador where people come out with some really sharp and interesting perspectives on the issue.
The whole traveler/tourist distinction is really at the heart of the way we think about travel, of the way we think about what the meaning and purpose of travel is, and whether it’s beneficial to local communities and to the construction of a healthier more empathetic world, or not.
“I wasn’t on vacation. Instead I was living ordinary life in an extraordinary place.”
I think that sums up what I’ve come to realize about myself as a traveler–I backpacked across South America, learned Spanish, and loved every second of it–but now, I want to live some place, I want to drink coffee there and walk around on Sunday mornings and come back to a neighborhood where I live. That’s what I’m doing in Japan, and what I do in Mexico (although much more temporarily in the former, and permanently in the latter).
When you live and work somewhere, you inevitably have to become familiar with the daily rhythms of at least some part of the local population. Even if I never talked to a Japanese person, I’d have to take the subway every morning and every evening and that process brings about a sort of absorption of local place and culture, although obviously I’d never use that to claim I understand Japan.
It is an entirely different thing than traveling somewhere. And I think that’s what John has hit on here, in a really eloquent way–the difference between living and and working in some place and passing through as a traveler on “vacation.”
↵ -
My issue with it is the labeling. Although i guess to discuss it you need to label it. But then comes the danger of having to pick the label that you fit in best, which, quite obviously, is not easy. At the far extremes you have people who only take 2 weeks of vacation per year and retire when they’re 65 – and then those that don’t have a place they call home but are constantly on the move. These two groups are easy to label.
It’s everything that falls in between that’s questionable. Does it matter though? Doesn’t this just lead back to holier-than-thouism that’s been featured here as well?
There are degrees in which we absorb a place/culture, depending how we interact with that place/culture. Living and working somewhere is up there. Joining in community events, making friends, being local, this I guess is the pinnacle.
But even as I write this, I’m thinking, so what? What’s the point? In a way I agree with Turner about not wanting to see this debate anymore, but not for the same reason. Not because “it will never be settled”, because that shouldn’t stop a discussion.
The traveler vs tourist debate seems to be more about who’s better than who, and not focused on things like benefits to community, environmental impact, understanding etc like Sarah mentions. These are questions that are best discussed as specific questions.
↵ -
Ah yes, the traveler/tourist debate. What does it matter? A “true traveler” is one that enjoys travel for the sake of travel. Maybe they’ll strike up conversations, maybe not. The point is to enjoy life and if travel (in whatever format) brings you joy then just do it! Who cares is you travel on a shoe-string budget or stay in a 5-star hotel…it’s your life!
↵ -
You can be a tourist and a traveler both if you keep your eyes and mind open.
Wonderful thoughts and provocative article. Thank you.
↵ -
Great article. We are about to go away for a year of shoestring travel in Africa and Asia. Though we could afford to stay in “nicer” places, we choose not too because I feel that I learn more, see more, meet more people when I travel in a more barebones way. In short, I get more out of it.
That said, travel is work. As the author said, “At times it was fun, mostly it was work and waiting….The good was tempered by the bad.” So, we plan to take a couple of vacations from our travels. We are setting aside time to chill out on a beach or a mountain and relax. For me that is the difference between travel and vacation. So we’ll be travelers and tourists. And I’m ok with that.
↵ -
Sounds nicely balanced. At the end of our first big travels (3 months around Europe) we took a “vacation” to Bulgaria, a one week last minute all-inclusive deal.
↵






















